Is Your Board Meeting Agenda Telling On You?

Intentional living is the art of making our own choices before others' choices make us.

A board agenda is more than a list of topics. It is a reflection of what a board believes is important. A board that spends 70% of its meeting receiving reports and approving routine items is telling you something about how it views its role. A board that consistently and intentionally makes room for mission, strategy, future opportunities, risk, impact, and difficult questions is telling you something very different.

If I want to understand how a board operates, I don’t necessarily need to sit through a year’s worth of meetings. Show me the agendas!

An agenda tells me what a board prioritizes, who is expected to talk, whether members are looking backward or forward, whether they are being asked to make decisions or simply receive information, and how much of their limited time is devoted to strategy versus operations. 

A board meeting is an important tool for communication with and among board members. Everyone is busy, and you want to make the most of your time together. That’s why I encourage nonprofit leaders to think of their agenda as a governance tool, not an administrative document.

 

Busy Does Not Equal High-Performing

Boards can have packed agendas, beautiful reports, a lot of discussions, votes and activity … and still not be doing particularly effective governance.

A high-performing board asks:

“What is the most important use of our collective brainpower right now?”

Rather than:

“What do we need to get through tonight?”

I’ve sat in plenty of board meetings where the agenda was packed, everyone was busy, and a tremendous amount of information was shared. Yet when the meeting ended, I wasn’t always sure what the board had actually accomplished.

Busy is not the same as productive. And productive is not necessarily the same as effective governance. 

 

Start With the Work, Not the Agenda

Rather than starting with: “What should be on our next board agenda?” start with: “What does this board need to accomplish over the next 3, 6, or 12 months?”

Instead of looking at each board meeting as an isolated event, map the important governance work across the year. What does the board need to know? What decisions will it need to make? What strategic conversations need time? What skills or knowledge do members need to develop? What milestones should the board be monitoring?

Then you use that information to build the meeting calendar and agendas. This is called Agenda Mapping and it is much more intentional than simply recycling the previous meeting’s agenda or randomly adding topics that come to mind. Agenda Mapping thoughtfully connects the board’s work across the year, rather than treating each meeting as a stand-alone event.

 

Build the Year Before You Build the Meeting

High-performing boards don’t create each agenda from scratch. They look at the annual governance calendar, as well as the organization’s strategic priorities, to determine when important conversations need to happen.

Here’s a very simplified example of what this might look like. Your organization’s annual governance calendar will – and should – look different. 

Quarter Possible Governance Focus
Q1 Strategic priorities, annual goals, board development, financial outlook
Q2 Program impact, community trends, fundraising strategy, board engagement
Q3 Strategic progress, risk, future opportunities, succession
Q4 Evaluation, budget, next year’s priorities, board self-assessment

The exact topics will vary by organization; yet the principle is simple: Don’t let the calendar dictate your governance. Let your governance priorities dictate the calendar.

 

Give Every Agenda Item a Job

Every item should have a clearly identified purpose. For example:

  • Inform – What does the board need to know?
  • Discuss – What requires collective thinking?
  • Decide – What decision does the board need to make?
  • Develop – What knowledge or skills do board members need?
  • Connect – How does this reconnect members to the mission, each other, community, or stakeholders?
  • Monitor – What needs ongoing oversight?
  • Evaluate – What are we learning about organizational performance?
  • Act – What needs to happen as a result? 

You may notice that “report” didn’t make this list. While there is often a lot of reporting that goes on in board meetings, the reports should have a bigger purpose. Maybe it’s a format for informing the board or developing their knowledge. Perhaps it demonstrates performance for monitoring impact or gauging reach.  

When inserting a report into the agenda, ask the question: Why does the board need this information? What are they supposed to do with it? A report just for the sake of reporting could be delivered over email and may not warrant valuable space on the board agenda.

 

Stop Giving Every Topic Equal Weight

Not every agenda item deserves 15 minutes. And not every item deserves to be discussed at all. Consider categorizing items as:

  • Consent: Things members have reviewed and can approve efficiently.
  • Monitoring: Information the board needs to oversee.
  • Discussion: Issues requiring collective thought.
  • Decision: Issues requiring board action.
  • Strategic Conversation: Issues where the board needs to wrestle with possibilities, implications, or tradeoffs.

The amount of time given to an issue should reflect its importance – not how long the report happens to be.

 

Protect the “Thinking Time”

Many boards say they want to be strategic, but they don’t actually schedule time to think strategically. They let other things, like routine reports, lengthy committee updates, or irrelevant tangents take over and hijack their meetings. If every meeting is packed with updates, committee reports and routine business, strategic thinking gets whatever scraps of time remain.

High-performing boards reserve the time before the meeting happens. Protecting time for high-level thinking requires a commitment from everyone – especially the Board Chair. Strong meeting leadership, combined with tools like time allotments, a timekeeper, and agreed-upon expectations for board member participation, can help keep meetings on track.

Board retreats can create a concentrated opportunity for this kind of thinking, but strategic thinking shouldn’t be reserved for an annual retreat. Well-designed board meetings should continue those conversations throughout the year. 

Strategic conversations require:

  • Context
  • Good questions
  • Multiple perspectives
  • Time
  • Sometimes uncomfortable disagreement
  • The ability to explore before deciding

Well designed board meetings can perpetuate high-level thinking and ensure that strategies developed at the retreat don’t live on as good intentions. 

 

Design Questions, Not Just Topics

One of the simplest ways to improve a board agenda is to stop writing agenda items as nouns and start writing them as questions. 

For example, if membership is an important issue, instead of putting “Membership Report” on the agenda, consider: “What are we learning about changes in membership, and what implications might those changes have for our strategy?”

Or, instead of: “Fundraising Update” ask: “What needs to change with our fundraising strategy to reach our three-year revenue goals?”

Finally, instead of: “Staffing Update,” include the question: “What organizational capacity will we need in order to accomplish our strategic priorities?”

Boards need to be intentional about the conversations they have, not just the information they receive. The topic tells you what you’re talking about. The question tells you why you’re talking about it.

 

Make the Agenda a Shared Leadership Tool

The agenda is one of the places where the Executive Director and Board Chair practice shared leadership. The board meeting agenda should not be something the Exec throws together, with the Chair approving it or maybe just seeing when they show up to the meeting. Creation of the agenda should be a shared leadership responsibility between the Board Chair and the Executive Director. 

It’s a shared responsibility because the Executive Director brings organizational context, insight into emerging issues, the opportunities that are popping up, the risks to be aware of and the perspective of the staff. All things that the Board Chair does not see because they are not working in the organization on a daily basis. 

On the other hand, the Board Chair brings the governance perspective, understanding of board dynamics, a focus on strategic priorities, questions that only the board can address and awareness of where the board needs development. These are important perspectives that the Exec won’t necessarily be attuned to as they are working hard to run the organization. 

In partnership they ask: “What does this board need to spend its time doing?”

High performing boards often schedule a standing agenda-planning conversation between the ED and Board Chair a couple weeks prior to the board meeting. Depending on the organization’s structure, the Board Secretary may also be part of this conversation, particularly when they are responsible for board communications and meeting materials. 

 

Leave Room for the Unexpected—Without Becoming Reactive

Intentional doesn’t mean rigid. Anyone who has worked in the nonprofit sector for any period of time knows that even with the best laid plans, something unexpected will inevitably pop up. Things like:

  • A major funding opportunity
  • Leadership transition
  • Community crisis
  • Regulatory change
  • Significant financial development
  • Unexpected partnership opportunity

are important and need to be addressed. A good agenda has enough structure to keep the board focused and enough flexibility to respond to something important.

With a reactive board everything urgent gets onto the agenda.

Intentional boards don’t ignore urgent issues. They put urgency in context and determine whether the issue is actually important enough to displace something else.

 

The “Agenda Test”

Before finalizing an agenda, ask yourself these eight questions:

  1. Why are we meeting?
  2. What does the board need to accomplish?
  3. Which items require board-level thinking or decision-making?
  4. What can be handled through the consent agenda or written communication?
  5. Where are we creating space for strategic conversation?
  6. What questions do we want board members wrestling with?
  7. Are we spending the most time on our most important priorities?
  8. What do we want members to leave the meeting understanding, deciding, or doing?

To help you stay focused on creating effective board meetings, I’ve developed this High-Performing Board Agenda Checklist for you. But here’s the thing: It’s easy to create a good-looking agenda. The real test is whether the agenda reflects how your board actually spends its time.

 

Challenge

If after reading this, you believe your organization’s board agendas might be saying a lot about the focus of your board, I have a Three-Minute Challenge for you. Pull out your last three board agendas, then ask:

  • Look Backward: How much time was spent reporting on what already happened?
  • Look Forward: How much time was spent thinking about what comes next?
  • Count the Talking: How much time did board members spend receiving information?
  • Count the Thinking: How much time did they spend thinking, questioning, deciding, and shaping the future?

If you discover that most of your board’s time is spent looking backward and receiving information, don’t beat yourself up. That’s incredibly common. But now you have something to work with.

Your board’s time is one of its most valuable resources. Don’t use it simply to get through the agenda. Design the agenda so your board can do the work only a board can do: govern well, think strategically, make thoughtful decisions, open doors, and help move the mission forward.

The next time you look at your board agenda, don’t just ask, “What are we talking about?” Ask, “Is this the best use of this board’s time?”

Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss shifting your board meetings from “sit-n-gets” to strategic drivers for the important work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com 

From Reactive to Intentional: The Mindset Every Nonprofit Board Needs

If you're proactive, you focus on preparing. If you're reactive, you end up focusing on repairing.

The board packet lands in your inbox. By the time the meeting begins, there’s another staffing update, a budget concern, an unexpected facilities issue, and two new items that “just can’t wait.”

Before anyone realizes it, the meeting is over.

The board accomplished a lot. But did it accomplish the right things?

Too often, nonprofit boards mistake being busy for being strategic. The result is a board that spends most of its time reacting to today’s problems instead of intentionally shaping tomorrow’s organization.

It isn’t because board members don’t care. In fact, the opposite is usually true. They care deeply. They simply become trapped in a cycle where everything feels urgent and that urgency crowds out effective leadership.

High-performing nonprofit boards break that cycle. They intentionally create space to make decisions that move the organization toward its mission and long-term vision.

 

How it Starts

Most nonprofit boards don’t wake up one morning and decide to become reactive. It happens gradually.

A budget issue demands immediate attention. A staff vacancy creates uncertainty. A donor has concerns. A grant deadline moves up. Before long, every board meeting revolves around whatever feels most urgent in the moment.

Months pass. Then years.

The organization stays busy, but the board rarely has time to ask the bigger questions:

  • Are we moving toward our vision?
  • What opportunities are we missing?
  • What decisions today will strengthen this organization five years from now?

The strongest nonprofit boards understand that good governance isn’t simply responding to today’s challenges. It’s intentionally making decisions that shape tomorrow’s success.

 

Urgency Isn’t the Enemy

Nonprofits exist to solve complex community challenges, so unexpected issues are inevitable. Every organization will face staffing changes, financial pressures, facility concerns, shifting community needs, and other unforeseen circumstances. Responding to those issues is part of responsible governance.

The problem begins when urgency becomes the lens through which every decision is made.

It is management’s role to solve today’s operational challenges.
It is the board’s role to ensure today’s decisions don’t compromise tomorrow’s mission.

When boards become consumed by operational issues, they unintentionally step away from the governance responsibilities that only they can fulfill—setting direction, ensuring sustainability, and stewarding the organization’s future.

When boards spend meeting after meeting focused only on the latest crisis, they unwittingly trade leadership for management. Instead of asking where the organization needs to be in three to five years, they spend their time solving the problem directly in front of them. Strategic priorities are postponed. Important conversations are deferred. Long-term opportunities are overlooked because there is never a “good time” to discuss them.

Ironically, a board that is constantly reacting often creates more urgency. Deferred maintenance becomes a costly repair. A lack of succession planning turns a staff departure into a leadership crisis. Failure to invest in fundraising or technology leads to future financial strain. By focusing exclusively on today’s problems, boards may unknowingly create tomorrow’s emergencies.

Intentional boards understand this dynamic. They recognize that while they cannot control every challenge their organization will face, they can control how they respond. They distinguish between what is truly urgent and what simply feels urgent. They resist the temptation to make significant decisions without adequate information or thoughtful discussion. Most importantly, they protect time to focus on the mission, strategic priorities, and the long-term health of the organization—even when immediate concerns are demanding their attention.

The most effective boards don’t ignore fires. They simply refuse to let every meeting become a fire drill. The goal isn’t to eliminate urgency. That’s impossible. The goal is to prevent urgency from becoming the board’s default mode of governance. 

 

Symptoms of a Reactive Board

A reactive board often:

  • Spends nearly every meeting reviewing reports rather than discussing strategy.
  • Focuses on solving today’s problems instead of preventing tomorrow’s.
  • Makes decisions with incomplete information because something feels urgent.
  • Constantly changes priorities.
  • Allows the loudest or most urgent issue to determine the agenda rather than strategic priorities.
  • Rarely evaluates whether previous decisions actually worked.
  • Ends meetings with more questions than decisions because conversations wander from issue to issue.
  • Leaves meetings exhausted instead of energized.

Many board members don’t even realize this pattern has developed because it feels productive.

 

What Intentional Boards Do Differently

Rather than asking: “What problem do we need to solve today?”

They ask: “What decision best advances our mission?”

Effective governance doesn’t happen by accident. It is the result of boards making conscious choices about how they spend their time, what questions they ask, and how they approach decisions. While every organization is different, high-performing boards tend to share several common practices.

 

They Return Repeatedly to the Mission and Strategic Priorities

The mission isn’t just a statement on the wall—it’s the filter through which every significant decision should pass.

Before approving a new program, making a major investment, or shifting priorities, intentional boards ask questions such as:

  • How does this advance our mission?
  • Does this align with our strategic plan?
  • If we say “yes” to this, what are we saying “no” to?

When boards consistently bring conversations back to the mission and strategic priorities, they reduce the likelihood of “mission drift” and ensure their decisions contribute to the organization’s long-term vision rather than simply responding to immediate pressures.

 

They Use Data Instead of Emotion

Passion for the mission is one of the greatest strengths of nonprofit board members. However, passion alone should not drive governance decisions.

Boards that govern well seek evidence before making significant choices. They review financial trends, program outcomes, community needs assessments, fundraising data, and stakeholder feedback. They ask for facts before forming conclusions and are willing to challenge assumptions—even their own.

Using data doesn’t eliminate compassion or intuition; it strengthens them by ensuring decisions are informed rather than impulsive.

 

They Pause Before Making Major Decisions

Not every decision requires immediate action.

Reactive boards often feel pressure to decide in the moment. Intentional boards understand that thoughtful governance sometimes requires slowing down. They ask for additional information, invite multiple perspectives, consider risks, and take the time necessary to evaluate options before committing to a course of action.

A brief pause can prevent months—or even years—of unintended consequences.

 

They Consider the Long-Term Impact

Every board decision creates ripple effects.

Rather than focusing only on today’s challenge, effective boards ask, “What will this decision mean for our organization one, three, or five years from now?”

They think about financial sustainability, organizational capacity, staff workload, community relationships, and future leadership. They recognize that decisions should not only solve today’s problems but also strengthen the organization’s ability to fulfill its mission well into the future.

 

They Build Agendas Around Strategic Conversations—Not Just Reports

Too many board meetings become a series of committee reports, financial updates, and informational presentations, leaving little time for meaningful discussion.

Intentional boards design agendas with purpose. Routine reports are often shared in advance through a consent agenda, allowing valuable meeting time to focus on strategic questions, emerging opportunities, organizational risks, and decisions that require the board’s collective wisdom. 

The goal is not simply to get through the agenda; it’s to have the conversations that matter most. (This article explores more about designing effective board meetings.)

 

They Reserve Time to Look Ahead

One of the simplest yet most powerful habits of effective boards is setting aside time to focus on the future.

Whether it’s fifteen minutes at every meeting, a quarterly strategy session, or an annual board retreat, they intentionally create opportunities to ask:

  • What trends are emerging in our community?
  • What opportunities should we be preparing for?
  • What risks do we see on the horizon?
  • How can we better position our organization for the future?

These conversations rarely feel urgent, but they are often the ones that have the greatest impact. They allow boards to anticipate change instead of merely reacting to it.

Ultimately, intentional boards understand that governance is about more than approving budgets and reviewing reports. Their greatest responsibility is to steward the organization’s future. By creating space for thoughtful discussion, asking better questions, and keeping the mission at the center of every decision, they help ensure the organization remains strong, relevant, and prepared for whatever lies ahead.

 

Creating Space for Strategic Thinking

In this previous article, I encouraged boards to get away from the boardroom and create dedicated time for strategic conversations. That’s because effective decision-making rarely happens in the final fifteen minutes of a meeting after financial reports and committee updates. It happens when boards intentionally create the space to think beyond today’s agenda.

 

Practical Questions Boards Should Ask

Instead of asking…     Can we afford this?

Ask…     Does this investment advance our mission?

Instead of…     What’s the quickest solution?

Ask…     What’s the wisest long-term decision?

Instead of…     How do we solve today’s issue?

Ask…     What system should we improve so this issue doesn’t keep returning?

Instead of…     What has everyone else done?

Ask…     What best serves our organization and community?

Instead of asking…     Who owns this problem? 

Ask…     What governance responsibility does the board have, and what should be delegated? 

 

My Challenge to You!

Every board will face unexpected challenges. That’s part of nonprofit leadership.

The question isn’t whether your board will have to react from time to time. The question is whether reaction has become your default way of governing.

Great boards are intentional. They protect time for strategic thinking. They evaluate decisions through the lens of mission. They resist allowing urgency to crowd out what matters most.

At your next board meeting, ask one simple question:

Are we spending more time reacting to today’s problems—or deliberately shaping tomorrow’s organization?

The answer may tell you more about your board’s effectiveness than any financial report ever could.

 

Intentional governance isn’t about eliminating uncertainty or preventing every crisis. Those moments are inevitable. It’s about building a board that is disciplined enough to pause, thoughtful enough to ask better questions, and courageous enough to make decisions that serve the mission—not just the moment.

Because in the end, the organizations that create lasting impact aren’t led by boards that simply react well. They’re led by boards that govern with purpose.

If your board is ready to move beyond reacting to the next challenge and begin governing with greater purpose and confidence, I’d love to help. Whether through board training, strategic planning, or governance consulting, together we can build a board that leads intentionally and positions your organization for long-term success.

Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss ways to advance your Board of Directors and the important work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com

Busting Nonprofit Myths

What People Get Wrong About the Sector

Say the words “nonprofit organization,” and many people immediately picture exhausted staff, tiny budgets, constant fundraising, and organizations barely holding things together. Others assume nonprofits are inefficient, unprofessional, or even vulnerable to fraud.

The reality is far more complex. Nonprofits are businesses with missions — and like any sector, they face challenges, accountability standards, and operational realities that are often misunderstood.

We’ll explore some of the more common misconceptions, but first – why does this even matter? 

  • Faulty thinking influences donor behavior, board expectations, funding decisions, and public trust — often in ways that weaken nonprofit effectiveness. When organizations are expected to operate without adequate staffing, infrastructure, or compensation, their ability to serve communities sustainably is compromised.
  • These harmful myths contribute to burnout, leadership turnover, underinvestment in infrastructure, and unrealistic expectations that can ultimately reduce organizational impact. 
  • Nonprofits provide critical services and require skilled leadership and infrastructure. Misunderstanding these realities can make it harder for nonprofits to attract and retain the talented leaders they need to thrive.

These misconceptions do more than create misunderstandings. They influence how nonprofits are funded, staffed, governed, and evaluated – often making it harder for organizations to achieve the very outcomes communities expect from them. Let’s examine some of the most common myths about the nonprofit sector, and what the reality actually looks like.

 

Myth #1: “Nonprofits Are Riddled With Fraud”

People sometimes assume nonprofits are less accountable than businesses. And the media’s stories about misuse of funds can reinforce the perception. 

That’s not to say fraud never occurs in the nonprofit sector. It definitely happens. However, according to a 2024 report from the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, only about 10% of occupational fraud cases studied occurred within nonprofit organizations — compared to much larger percentages in public and private companies, and government entities.

The reality is that the vast majority of nonprofits operate ethically and transparently. They face oversight from their Board of Directors, 990 IRS filings, grant reporting, audits, donor accountability, and state compliance requirements. 

When people assume nonprofits are inherently untrustworthy, organizations may struggle to build donor confidence, recruit qualified board members, or secure long-term investments that strengthen programs and operations.

This myth is perpetuated in part because people generally believe that a sector committed to making our world a better place is immune from corruption. So when it happens it receives a lot of attention. 

This particular myth highlights the importance of having an engaged, competent and thoughtful Board of Directors. Strong governance, financial controls, and investment in leadership and technology not only reduce fraud risk — they also strengthen organizational stability and public trust. 

Fraud is not a “nonprofit problem.” It is a human and organizational risk that exists in every sector.

Ironically, some of the same public expectations designed to keep nonprofits “lean” can actually make organizations less stable and more vulnerable. One of the most persistent examples is the belief that nonprofits should operate with little to no overhead.

 

Myth #2: “Nonprofits Should Have Little to No Overhead”

Donors have traditionally wanted 100% of donations to go directly to programs. Administrative costs are often viewed negatively.

The reality is that overhead is what allows programs to function effectively. Like any other business, some of the necessary investments include: accounting, technology, compliance, staffing, insurance, facilities, leadership, cybersecurity, fundraising systems, and training.

A nonprofit without overhead is like a hospital (many of which are nonprofit organizations) without electricity or a business without accounting. No one would question those businesses’ overhead needs. Yet a youth development organization is expected to get by without any staff, technology, or program supplies. 

Imagine a food pantry operating with outdated software, inadequate staffing, and no budget for volunteer training. Donors may celebrate the organization’s low overhead ratio, but those limitations can result in longer wait times, administrative errors, volunteer turnover, and fewer families served.

Starving organizations of infrastructure creates inefficiency. The pressure to minimize overhead is what often creates the very inefficiencies donors fear. Organizations operating without adequate staffing, technology, systems, or training spend more time managing crises and less time delivering meaningful impact. These limitations reduce capacity, weaken sustainability, and make long-term community impact significantly harder to achieve.

Fortunately, this is a misconception that is finally starting to turn. Many major philanthropic leaders and watchdog organizations now encourage evaluating: outcomes, impact, and governance, rather than obsessing over overhead percentages alone.

The pressure to minimize overhead often spills over into another damaging assumption: that nonprofit professionals should sacrifice fair compensation for the mission.

 

Myth #3: “Nonprofit Staff Should Be Paid Very Little and Work Endless Hours”

The misconception here is that passion should replace compensation. There is often an expectation of self-sacrifice. Some researchers and sector leaders have explored whether, because nonprofit workforces are disproportionately female, cultural expectations around caregiving and sacrifice may influence perceptions about compensation.

The reality of this one is that nonprofit work requires highly skilled professionals in the areas of: leadership, finance, counseling, program management, fundraising, compliance, strategic planning, communications and much more!

Mission-driven work does not eliminate the need for sustainable wages. Chronic underpayment contributes to: burnout, turnover, staffing shortages, and a loss of institutional knowledge and organizational momentum. Constant turnover disrupts relationships, weakens program continuity, and forces organizations into cycles of recruitment and recovery instead of growth and innovation.

Caring deeply about a mission should not require financial instability or exhaustion. 

Many nonprofit professionals are deeply committed and willing to go above and beyond. But organizations cannot sustainably build effective missions around chronic exhaustion and unsustainable sacrifice.

Another likely reason for this misconception is the final myth we’re going to examine –  nonprofit work is somehow “easier” or less demanding than work in the corporate sector. 

 

Myth #4: “Working in Nonprofit Is Easier Than Other Sectors”

Finally, some people view nonprofit work as slower-paced or less rigorous.  There can be assumptions that nonprofits are less professionalized.

Nonprofit professionals often manage: limited resources, high community needs, complex funding restrictions, emotionally intense work, multiple stakeholder groups, and public scrutiny. Staff are frequently expected to do more with less. Nonprofit leaders must balance: business operations, social impact, compliance, fundraising, and community engagement simultaneously.

Nonprofit work is not “less than” other sectors — it is often more complex because organizations must balance mission and sustainability at the same time.

The skills required in nonprofit leadership are highly transferable and sophisticated. Many nonprofit leaders effectively operate small-to-mid-sized businesses with significant accountability responsibilities.

When nonprofit work is viewed as “easier” or less professional, organizations may face reduced investment in leadership development, compensation, staffing, and operational support — despite managing highly complex community challenges.

 

Let’s Change the Narrative

Nonprofits are professional organizations, not passion projects. Sustainable organizations create stronger and more consistent community impact. When nonprofits are underfunded, understaffed, or expected to operate without proper infrastructure, communities ultimately feel the effects through reduced capacity, interrupted services, and diminished long-term outcomes.

If we want nonprofits to solve complex community challenges, we must stop expecting them to operate without the very resources, talent, and infrastructure that make meaningful impact possible.

Most people who work in nonprofits already understand the reality behind these myths. Sometimes it can be hard to articulate the truth, or they may feel like they are the only ones working to change these misconceptions. 

For those who are volunteers, funders, and community members, this may be a shift in how you think about, and how you can support philanthropic work. Challenging these misconceptions is not just about improving perceptions of nonprofits — it is about strengthening the organizations communities rely on every day.

Changing these perceptions begins with stronger governance, realistic expectations, and a commitment to investing in nonprofit success. Every nonprofit is different and has unique needs and challenges when it comes to engaging their governance volunteers. Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss ways to advance your Board of Directors and the work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com

Go Away! Together. As a team.

Why Nonprofit Board Retreats Matter More Than You Think

Most nonprofit board meetings follow a familiar rhythm.

An agenda gets approved. Reports are shared. A few decisions are made. Time runs out before the “real” conversation can happen. Everyone leaves feeling like they did their job—but not always like they moved the organization forward.

This is what I think of as checkbox governance. The work gets done on paper. The boxes get checked. But the deeper work of governing – thinking strategically, building alignment, strengthening relationships – rarely gets the time or space it actually requires.

That’s where board retreats come in.

Not as a luxury. Not as a nice-to-have. But as a necessary disruption to the pattern.

Boards don’t become more effective by squeezing more into a two-hour meeting. They become more effective when they create space to think, connect, and lead differently.

 

What a Board Retreat Is (and What It Isn’t)

Let’s start by clearing up a common misconception: a board retreat is not just a longer board meeting in a different location.

If the agenda looks the same, the dynamic will be the same.

A true retreat is a strategic pause. It’s an intentional step away from routine business to focus on the things that rarely fit neatly into an agenda:

  • Big-picture thinking
  • Honest conversations
  • Deep-dive into critical issues facing the organization
  • Relationship-building
  • Alignment around purpose and direction

It’s also not purely social. Yes, there’s often more connection and informal conversation—but that’s not separate from the work. It is the work. Strong governance depends on trust, and trust doesn’t develop in tightly managed agenda slots.

A retreat sits in that productive middle ground: structured, but spacious. Focused, but not rushed.

 

Why Retreats Matter: Moving Beyond Checkbox Governance

If regular meetings are where boards manage, retreats are where boards lead.

Here’s what becomes possible when you step outside the usual routine.

1. Space for the Conversations That Actually Matter

In most meetings, strategy gets squeezed between reports and approvals—if it shows up at all.

A retreat creates room to ask bigger questions:

    • Are we still aligned with our mission in how we operate today?
    • What does impact really look like over the next three-ish years?
    • What are we not talking about that we should be?

These aren’t quick conversations. And they’re not supposed to be. But without them, boards drift into oversight without direction.

2. Stronger Relationships, Better Governance

Boards are made up of people, but many operate like a collection of roles.

Retreats shift that dynamic.

They give board members a chance to:

    • Get to know each other beyond titles and committees
    • Build trust through real conversations
    • Understand different perspectives in a more human way

This matters more than many boards realize. Because when trust is low, conversations stay surface-level. When trust is strong, boards can navigate complexity, disagreement, and decision-making far more effectively.

You can’t shortcut that in a standard meeting.

3. Increased Engagement and Ownership

Disengaged boards don’t usually start that way. More often, they become disengaged over time—when meetings feel repetitive, roles feel unclear, and opportunities to contribute feel limited.

A well-designed retreat can interrupt that pattern. It creates space for board members to: reconnect with why they said yes to serving in the first place, clarify expectations and responsibilities, and understand where they fit into the bigger picture.

When people feel connected to the purpose and clear about their role, engagement stops being something you have to chase.

4. Alignment Between Board and Leadership

Even in strong organizations, misalignment between the board and executive leadership can quietly build over time.

Not because anyone is doing something wrong—but because there isn’t enough space for shared reflection.

Retreats allow for:

    • Candid conversation about priorities and direction
    • Clarification of roles between governance and management
    • A stronger partnership between board leadership and the executive director

Without that alignment, even well-intentioned boards can create friction instead of forward momentum.

5. A Chance to Reset—Before You Have To

Some boards plan retreats proactively. Others wait until something feels off.

In reality, retreats are most valuable before things break down. They’re especially useful when:

    • The board feels disconnected or low-energy
    • Communication is strained or “off”
    • Meetings have become overly tactical
    • New members are joining and need integration
    • The organization is entering a period of change or growth

A retreat can serve as a reset point—a moment to step back, recalibrate, and move forward with intention.

What Makes a Retreat Worthwhile

Not all retreats deliver on their potential. The difference usually comes down to intentionality.

Effective retreats tend to have:

  • A clear purpose (beyond “we should do this”)
  • Thoughtful facilitation that creates space for participation
  • A balance between structure and flexibility
  • Time for both strategic discussion and relationship-building
  • A plan for what happens after the retreat ends

What they don’t have is an overpacked agenda or a series of back-to-back presentations. That’s just a meeting in disguise.

 

Where Retreats Go Wrong

If you’ve ever heard someone say, “We did a retreat once—it wasn’t very helpful,” it is usually because of one of these common pitfalls:

  • Treating it like a regular board meeting in a new setting
  • Trying to accomplish too much in too little time
  • Failing to define clear outcomes
  • Allowing a few voices to dominate the conversation
  • Not following through on what was discussed
  • Lack of an outside perspective to keep energies focused and facilitate difficult discussions

A retreat without intention doesn’t just waste time—it reinforces the very patterns you’re trying to break.

 

Making the Case: Time and Cost vs. Impact

When organizations are considering a board retreat, two objections come up consistently: time and cost.

Board members (like everyone) are busy. Budgets are tight. And a retreat can feel like an added burden.

Because effective board leadership is crucial to any organization, it is worth reframing the question.

  • What is the cost of a disengaged board?
  • What is the cost of unclear priorities?
  • What is the cost of meetings that check boxes but don’t move the mission forward?

Compared to those situations, a retreat isn’t an extra expense. It’s an investment in governance capacity.

And strong governance isn’t accidental—it’s built.

 

From Obligation to Opportunity

At their best, nonprofit boards don’t just oversee organizations. They help shape their direction, strengthen their impact, and steward their future.

That kind of leadership doesn’t happen in the margins of an agenda. It requires space. It requires intention. And sometimes, it requires stepping outside the boardroom entirely.

A retreat isn’t about doing more. It’s about doing what matters—better.

Because if we’re honest, checkbox governance is easy.

But meaningful governance? –> That takes time, trust, and a willingness to do things differently.

 

Every nonprofit is different and has unique needs and challenges when it comes to engaging their governance volunteers. If you’re considering taking your team away, use this handy checklist to make sure your experience is a success! Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss planning a retreat and how best to advance your Board of Directors and the work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com

Engaging New Board Members: Setting the Tone Early (Without Overcomplicating It)

Engage your team, unleash success. ~ anonymous

How to welcome, activate, and integrate new or returning board members for a strong start.

Here we are — the sixth and final article in this six-part series outlining my nonprofit board development process!

So far, we’ve clarified what your organization truly needs from its board. We’ve defined expectations. We’ve explored how to identify and source the right prospects, how to recruit and vet them well, and how to formally invite and onboard them.

Now you have these amazing and eager new board members.

The question becomes: what do you do with them?

Getting new members involved in something that is manageable yet meaningful can feel like a delicate balancing act. Push too hard and they feel overwhelmed. Hold back too much and they disengage. Yet this window — the first 30 to 60 days — is one of the most important predictors of long-term retention and performance.

There’s something powerful about a reset point. For many boards, the beginning of a calendar year or the start of a new board term creates a natural moment to refocus. Energy is high. Intentions are fresh. People are open to clarity.

But it doesn’t have to be January for this to matter.

Anytime new members join — or anytime a board recommits to its work — the early days set the tone for everything that follows. Early engagement isn’t just about being welcoming. It’s about shaping culture, building accountability, and establishing momentum.

 

Why Early Engagement Is Strategic — Not Administrative

Board engagement follows a predictable pattern. When someone first joins, they are attentive. They are listening carefully. They want to contribute. Most significantly, they are evaluating whether this feels like a good investment of their time and energy.

If that early energy isn’t harnessed, it dissipates.

You’ve likely seen it. A new member who was enthusiastic in month one becomes quiet by month three. Someone misses one meeting, then another. The board chair or executive director finds themselves re-explaining priorities because alignment never fully took root.

This is not a motivation problem. It is an integration problem.

Strong early engagement does three things. It builds commitment, it prevents momentum from fading, and it aligns everyone around shared priorities from the start. If you want a high-functioning board, the onboarding window must be treated as strategic infrastructure — not administrative housekeeping.

 

Start With Belonging

In Article 5, we discussed the importance of a warm and thoughtful welcome. That principle continues here.

A personal message from the board chair or executive director does more than pass along information. It communicates, “You belong here.” When you express appreciation for their service, remind them why their perspective matters, and point them toward key resources, you are doing more than onboarding. You are affirming identity.

Similarly, creating an intentional orientation touchpoint — whether standalone or attached to a regular meeting — provides critical context. A mission refresher, an opportunity for members to share why they serve, and a clear overview of current goals all anchor new members in purpose rather than paperwork.

And do not underestimate the value of a peer mentor. Every board has its acronyms, history, and informal norms. Assigning a seasoned member as a board buddy accelerates integration in ways no manual ever could. It creates a safe space for questions and reduces the hesitation that often keeps new members quiet.

Belonging comes before contribution. But contribution must follow quickly.

 

Move Them From Observers to Contributors

New board members do not want to sit quietly for six months. They want to add value.

The key is to give them something that is real but not overwhelming. Invite them onto a committee immediately. Ask for feedback on a specific policy. Engage them in preparation for an upcoming event. Encourage them to introduce one potential community partner.

These are not busywork assignments. They are signals.

When new members experience an early win, something shifts. Confidence builds. Identity strengthens. They stop feeling like guests at the table and begin acting like governing partners. Momentum builds identity. The sooner they contribute meaningfully, the sooner they fully step into the role.

 

Clarify Expectations — For Everyone

This is also the moment to revisit expectations — not just with new members, but with returning ones as well.

Re-sharing your board expectations document (discussed in Article 2), attendance standards, giving and getting philosophy, and committee participation norms reinforces shared accountability. But clarity should not feel like compliance. It should feel like alignment.

Invite questions. Normalize confusion. Make it safe to say, “I’m not sure what that means.” Early clarification prevents later correction.

Most importantly, tie every expectation back to impact. Explain why attendance matters. Articulate how financial participation supports credibility. Connect preparation standards to effective governance. When members understand the purpose behind expectations, they experience them as meaningful rather than managerial.

 

Design the First Meetings Intentionally

The first meeting after onboarding is pivotal. It either confirms belonging or reinforces distance.

Equip members to participate by providing a concise briefing: a year-at-a-glance calendar, a snapshot of strategic plan progress, and a financial dashboard explained in plain language. You are not trying to overwhelm them — you are giving them the tools to engage intelligently.

Equally important is how the meeting feels. A simple check-in question can humanize the room. Creating space for informal connection strengthens relational trust. Intentionally inviting new voices into the conversation communicates that contribution is expected and welcomed.

Board culture is not accidental. It is shaped, week by week, meeting by meeting. (Want more about crafting effective board meetings? Read about it here.)

 

Don’t Forget Your Returning Members

Engagement is not only about newcomers.

Returning board members are culture carriers. The way they participate signals what is normal. Assigning small leadership roles, inviting committee chairs to share their plans, or asking seasoned members to articulate what effective board service looks like reinforces shared ownership.

When veteran members are re-engaged, new members see a model of commitment in action.

 

Close the First Month With Intention

Close the onboarding window intentionally. Simple gestures matter:

  • A short “thank you for serving” note.
  • A brief onboarding feedback survey.
  • An open invitation for a 1:1 with the executive director or board chair.

This communicates something essential: Your service is not assumed. It is valued.

These gestures are small. Their impact is not.

 

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Well-meaning boards often stumble in predictable ways. They overload new members with documents but neglect relationships. They wait too long to assign meaningful responsibility. And they assume returning members don’t need re-engagement. Or they expect new members to simply “figure it out.”

None of these approaches build culture. They erode it.

Board culture is engineered — either intentionally or by default.

 

A Simple Engagement Challenge

You don’t need to overhaul your entire onboarding process this year. Choose one action:

  • Schedule a 30-minute welcome conversation with each new board member.
  • Assign every new member a board buddy.
  • Clarify and re-share board expectations at your next meeting.

Small, early investments compound over time.

Engaged boards are not the result of good intentions alone. They are the result of leaders who deliberately create the conditions where caring turns into contribution.

 

Every nonprofit is different and has unique needs and challenges when it comes to engaging their governance volunteers. Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss ways to advance your Board of Directors and the work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com

New Year’s Resolutions for Nonprofit Leaders (That Might Actually Stick)

January is the season of fresh starts, lofty goals, and bold declarations. In the nonprofit world, that often translates into resolutions like “We will finally meet the budget,” “We will serve more people,” or “This will be the year everything magically feels less hard.”

Those are worthy goals. But if history tells us anything, it’s that hitting those outcomes requires more than grit and caffeine.

So instead of focusing only on what you want to achieve this year, I want to suggest a few resolutions that focus on how you lead. These won’t just make your year more enjoyable—they’ll actually help you get closer to those big, ambitious goals.

Here are a few nonprofit-leader New Year’s resolutions worth considering:

1. Commit to balance (or something resembling it)

You’re no good to your organization if you’re completely burned out, chronically stressed, and one minor inconvenience away from tears. This doesn’t mean bubble baths fix everything—but it does mean protecting your energy, setting reasonable boundaries, and acknowledging that rest is a leadership skill.

2. Tell thoughtful stories—not just impressive statistics

Yes, the numbers matter. Funders love them. Boards ask for them. But people connect with stories. Make a resolution to tell fewer “look how busy we are” stories and more “here’s why this work matters” stories. Bonus points if they include nuance, dignity, and real humanity.

3. Really connect with your agency’s “friends”

You know the ones—donors, volunteers, partners, staff, community champions, etc.. This year, aim to move beyond transactional relationships. Fewer mass emails, more genuine check-ins. Fewer asks, more listening. People don’t want to feel like an ATM; they want to feel like they belong.

4. Reflect on why you got into—and stay in—this work

Nonprofit leadership can quietly turn passion into obligation. Make time to revisit your “why.” What pulled you into this work in the first place? What still keeps you here? Reconnecting with that purpose can be grounding on the days when the spreadsheet wins.

5. Celebrate small wins (even when the big win isn’t here yet)

Did a board member step up? Did a program participant have a breakthrough? Did a meeting end early? Celebrate it. Waiting for the big milestone often means missing the momentum built by small, meaningful progress.

6. Focus on culture, not just output

Culture isn’t a “nice to have.” It’s the invisible force shaping how your team shows up every day. Make 2026 the year you pay attention to how people feel at work—not just what they produce. Healthy culture fuels sustainability.

7. Outsource the stuff you’re not good at—or simply don’t have capacity for

You do not get a gold star for doing everything yourself. If there are tasks that drain you, distract you, or consistently fall to the bottom of the list, consider outsourcing them. Your time is valuable, even if the nonprofit sector sometimes pretends otherwise.

8. Delegate like you mean it

Delegation isn’t dumping tasks and disappearing. It’s trusting others, setting clear expectations, and letting people grow. This year, resolve to stop being the bottleneck. Leadership isn’t about being indispensable—it’s about building capacity beyond yourself.

None of these resolutions require a new grant, a bigger staff, or a miracle. They don’t even require a whole bunch of extra time. What they do require is intention, reflection, and a willingness to lead differently.

And if nothing else, may this be the year you stop expecting yourself to be a superhero and start leading like a human.

Finding balance in the nonprofit sector can be challenging. Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss goals that will make your life as a nonprofit leader easier! 

 

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com 

Recruiting, Vetting, Tracking: Building A Board with Intention

Welcome to the fourth article in this six-part series outlining my nonprofit board development process.

  • Article 1 focused on clarifying what your organization needs from its board.
  • Article 2 explored setting expectations to guide and hold members accountable.
  • Article 3 talked about determining where a prospect is on the casual – connected – committed continuum, and where to find them. 

Now that you’re clear about your Ideal Board Profile, your expectations, and where to look for your hot, warm, and cool prospects, the next logical step is to figure out what to do with those individuals you’re interested in recruiting and vetting.

One Coffee Meeting Isn’t a Strategy

Let’s name it: many organizations rely on a single, informal strategy to recruit board members. Too often, that strategy is something like: “the Executive Director has coffee with someone and then invites them to join the board.”

And yes – coffee can absolutely be part of a successful cultivation plan. But it shouldn’t be the only strategy. A strong recruitment process is thoughtful, varied, and relationship-based. It offers multiple opportunities for prospects to engage with your mission, your team, and your work before any invitation to serve is extended.

Depending on your mission, you may have plenty of natural on-ramps for engagement – or you may need to get creative. Either way, this phase is about intentionally deepening relationships, gathering insights, and laying the groundwork for informed board invitations.

 

Deepening Relationships: From Casual to Committed

Let’s break down the process of moving prospects along the continuum from casual to connected, and then to committed. This article doesn’t focus on moving people from “clueless” to “casual” – that’s really a marketing conversation. Instead, we’ll start with prospects who already have some awareness that your organization exists.

From Casual to Connected

Casual prospects might be:

  • On your newsletter list
  • Friends, neighbors, or vendors
  • Occasional attendees at community events
  • Social media followers who occasionally comment or share

Your goal with casual prospects is not to make a hard sell for board service. It’s to educate, build trust, and invite light-touch participation that draws them deeper into your mission.

Some examples:

  • Invite newsletter subscribers to make a specific in-kind donation.
    Example: A domestic violence shelter might host a winter coat drive.
  • Host an event designed to share your work.
    Example: A historic preservation foundation could offer a public presentation about upcoming renovations.
  • Offer regular tours or informal gatherings.
    Example: An animal shelter might hold a weekly “Yappy Hour” where guests can play with animals and meet staff.

Here’s the key: These interactions aren’t passive experiences. Staff and board members should be intentional – trained to listen for interest, ask good questions, and take note of promising prospects who align with the board’s current needs.

And importantly, these experiences should not just deepen relationships with a staff person. They should connect the individual more meaningfully with the organization as a whole. The prospect should walk away with a sense of your organization’s culture, values, and impact – something bigger than one person or one conversation.

From Connected to Committed

Connected prospects have already taken a few steps toward engagement. They might:

  • Attend events or fundraisers
  • Donate regularly 
  • Volunteer in programs or for events
  • Follow your work with genuine interest

These individuals already care. Now your job is to nurture that care and explore their potential for greater involvement.

Here are some ideas:

  • Invite them to coffee or lunch with the Executive Director or a board member. Not to pitch them for the board, but to learn more about them and share more about your mission.
  • Ask for help with a meaningful but manageable task. People feel more committed when they can contribute their time and talents in a way that matters.
  • Offer a personalized tour or an insider experience. Seeing your work up-close builds deeper connection and often sparks curiosity.
  • Invite them to serve on a short-term committee or task force. Choose something that matches their skills or interests.

Each of these strategies serves two purposes:

  1. Deepen the relationship.
  2. Offer real insight into how the prospect shows up – how they think, work with others, communicate, and follow through. That information is invaluable for your vetting process.

And again, think beyond a single relationship. How can this person feel connected to the organization – not just the Executive Director or a charismatic board member? In healthy board cultures, people stay connected because they care about the mission, the impact, and the team.

 

Vetting: From Committed to Board Member

Once someone is clearly invested – talking about your mission in the community, showing up consistently, supporting in multiple ways – it’s time to seriously consider them for board service. But remember: not everyone who’s deeply committed should serve on your board!

After you’ve built a foundation of relationship and engagement, vetting ensures that your decision to invite someone onto the board is grounded in intention – not desperation.Vetting helps you evaluate whether a prospect is ready and right for board service at this time. It also gives your team a shared framework for making informed, unbiased decisions.

Here are five key areas to consider during vetting:

1. Alignment with the Mission

  • Do they care deeply about your cause?
  • Have they shown interest over time (not just in one conversation)?
  • Can they speak about your work in a way that’s passionate and informed?

In-Action Example: During a one-on-one conversation, ask them to describe why they’re interested in your organization. A strong candidate will talk about their personal connection to the mission or their passion for your impact – not just board service in general.

2. Ability to Meet Board Expectations

  • Have they reviewed your Board Expectations (from Article 2)?
  • Do they have the time, energy, and resources to contribute meaningfully?
  • Are they willing to engage in fundraising, governance, and strategic thinking?

In-Action Example: Send them your Board Expectations document ahead of time, then discuss it together. Ask how they’ve navigated similar responsibilities in the past. Listen for thoughtful questions, openness, and any signs of hesitation – especially around time, fundraising, or fiduciary duties.

3. Fit with Current Board Composition

  • What perspectives, skills, or lived experiences do they bring?
  • Do they help fill gaps identified in your Ideal Board Profile (Article 1)?
  • Will they complement your existing team dynamics?

In-Action Example: Discuss the culture of the board and the intentional ways it is being shaped. Ask about what they look for in a team culture and how they see themselves supporting the one that has been created. 

4. Leadership and Follow-Through

  • Have they demonstrated follow-through in prior engagement (e.g., showing up to events, completing volunteer tasks)?
  • Are they reliable, respectful, and collaborative?

In-Action Example: After a meeting, follow up with a small task or resource (e.g., “Would you mind sending a short bio I can share with the committee?” or “Let me know if you’d like to review our financials before we reconnect.”). Notice whether they follow through promptly, ask questions, or leave it hanging.

5. Red Flags or Cautions

  • Are they overly critical of the organization without offering solutions?
  • Do they dominate conversations or show signs of being difficult to collaborate with?
  • Are there signs they’re seeking board service for prestige, not service?

When you are in need of board members, it can be difficult to consider turning someone away who is interested in serving. It feels like looking a gift horse in the mouth. Yet there is little value in filling a board slot with someone who doesn’t meet your needs, is not willing to fulfill your expectations, or who disrupts the culture of your board. 

📝 Pro Tip: Consider creating a brief evaluation form or scorecard for your board development committee or leadership team to use consistently across all prospects. It doesn’t need to be rigid—but it should help ground your conversations in shared values and expectations. Here is a sample Board Prospect Vetting Worksheet to get you started. 

 

Tracking: From Chaos to Clarity

Without a system for tracking your board prospects, you’re just relying on memory and scattered notes. A good tracking system helps you:

  • Avoid losing track of promising prospects
  • Prevent duplicate or premature asks
  • Monitor engagement over time
  • See the bigger picture of your board pipeline

At minimum, your tracking system should include:

  • Name and contact info
  • Where they are on the continuum: Casual, Connected, or Committed
  • Engagement activities to date: Tours, events, volunteer tasks, conversations
  • Notes on interests and skills
  • Board readiness status: Not ready, Ready for cultivation, Ready for ask
  • Assigned point person: Who’s nurturing the relationship?

You can use something as simple as a shared Google Sheet (here’s a sample), or as robust as a CRM (customer relationship management) platform. The goal is to make the invisible visible – to keep your board-building work intentional and forward-moving. 

Whether you’re just getting started or looking to upgrade your system, here are a few free or low-cost platforms that can support your tracking efforts:

  • Google Sheets + Google Forms – this free and simple platform is a great place to start if you are moving from having no system at all to wanting to put some structure to your tracking. Great if you are already using Google products. 
  • Airtable – combines spreadsheet functionality with database power. Good for small teams who want flexibility without technical support. Free for teams up to 5 users. 
  • HubSpot CRM – you can create different pipelines for different engagement strategies, such as casual – connected – committed. You can also assign owners, track communications, and log tasks. It’s free and can include automations or integrations with email. 
  • Trello – I use this system for tracking projects and relationships. It’s easy to move people along to different stages and include notes. This is free for the basic product and works great for us visual folks! 
  • Bloomerang Lite – is free for small nonprofits. It offers donor and volunteer tracking with engagement history and segmentation. Great for those organizations that foresee growing into needing a full fundraising CRM in the near future.  

 

Bringing It All Together

When you combine relationship-building, vetting, and tracking, you create a thoughtful, mission-centered pipeline for board development. You stop relying on luck or last-minute recruiting and instead start building a board that is aligned, prepared, and positioned to lead your organization well.

In the fifth article in this series, we’ll explore Making the Ask & Onboarding. This will include how to formally invite someone to serve on your board and welcome them into your organization in a way that is clear, inspiring, and sets the tone for success.

Because once you’ve invested in cultivating, vetting, and tracking a prospect, the invitation should feel like the natural next step – not a leap.

 

Every nonprofit is different and has unique needs and challenges when it comes to finding governance volunteers. Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss ways to advance your Board of Directors and the work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com

Understanding the Unique Needs of YOUR Board

If you don't know what it is you're looking for, you're never going to find it.

When a company is looking to hire a new employee, they often go through a rigorous process to find the right person. They craft a thoughtful, specific, and intentional job description, clarify the needs and expectations of the role, and reach out to colleagues and various platforms to post the job opening. There is usually an exhaustive screening, interviewing, evaluating, and vetting process. Finally, an onboarding and support system is put in place to help the new hire succeed. 

Ideally, all this effort pays off, and the new employee is a great fit for the organization. They feel appropriately challenged and supported and become a vital member of the team.

No one questions putting this much effort into hiring staff, even for part-time or entry-level positions. This is simply what you do to get the right person for the job.

Yet, when it comes to recruiting a new governance volunteer for a Board of Directors, there is often little to no process. Some organizations have an open application on their website and accept anyone interested. Others rely on informal coffee meetings, where a pleasant conversation leads to an invitation to join the board. 

Beyond needing warm bodies, not much thought is given to the specific skills, knowledge, experience, connections, temperament, or leadership abilities required to effectively guide the organization. Given that these individuals are responsible for the vision, strategy, impact, and financial stability of the nonprofit, this lack of intentionality is concerning. 

This article is the first in a six-part series on Building a Better Board. To start, we must get crystal clear on who and what your board truly needs.

Getting Specific: Why Narrowing Your Search Helps

It may seem counterintuitive to narrow your search. If you’re struggling to find board members, how could limiting your criteria make it easier? And if you’re willing to take anyone, why refine your focus at all?

The reality is that the more specific you are, the easier it becomes to identify suitable candidates. If you tell people you’re looking for “anyone willing to serve,” that doesn’t provide much direction. However, if you articulate exactly who you’re looking for—what skills, experience, or background they should have—it gives people a clear framework to help you find the right match. 

When I started my business, I kept things broad. With 30 years of nonprofit leadership experience, I could help a variety of clients. But when I told people I could do “a lot of things,” no one knew what to refer me for. My services were too vague.

So I narrowed my focus to working with small-to-medium nonprofits (under 15 years old) that needed help developing their Board of Directors. The result? More referrals and clearer connections because people understood exactly how I could help.

This doesn’t mean I turn down every client outside my niche—it simply helps me prioritize. The same applies to your board recruitment. Define what you need first, and then decide case by case whether to make exceptions.

Identifying Your Ideal Board Prospect (IBP)

In marketing, businesses define an Ideal Client Profile. Similarly, we will explore your Ideal Board Prospect (IBP) throughout this series.

Some key factors to consider when defining your IBP include:

  • Tasks that need to be managed
  • Skills and expertise
  • Education and lived experiences
  • Representation and community ties
  • Special interest groups
  • Connections and fundraising capacity
  • Temperament and personality styles
  • Comfort with risk
  • Board role (hands-on, fundraising, governance, etc.)

This is not an exhaustive list, but it provides a strong starting point. What else do you need to consider? Who would fit well with where your organization is in its development? Are there other factors that are unique and specific to your organization’s needs?Once you identify the traits that matter most, you may want to categorize them into “must-haves” and “nice-to-haves.” 

These discussions can be incredibly valuable for your current board. If your volunteers have not had these discussions before, be patient—shifting to a more strategic approach takes time and encouragement. 

Beyond Skills: The Importance of Personality in Board Composition

Beyond expertise and experience, how board members interact can significantly impact effectiveness. That’s where personality styles come in.

Personality differences often go unnoticed until conflicts arise. But by considering them in advance, you can build a more cohesive and functional board.

Many personality assessments exist—Myers-Briggs, DISC, StrengthsFinder, and more. While each categorizes people differently, they tend to group individuals into four general types:

  • Process-minded, people-focused
    • Nurturing and great listeners
    • Prefers to work behind the scenes
    • Deliberate in decision-making
  • Quick-minded, people-focused
    • High-energy and idea-driven
    • Great connectors
    • Often juggling multiple initiatives
  • Process-mined, task-focused
    • Detail-oriented and precise
    • Prefers structure and procedures
    • Prone to analysis paralysis
  • Quick-minded, task-focused
    • Thrives in fast-paced, high-pressure situations
    • Decisive and action-oriented
    • May overlook the human impact of decisions

There is great value in doing an official personality assessment. However, based on these very brief descriptions, you can probably already start to identify people in your life or on your team who fit into the different styles. This may help you understand why certain people can’t seem to work together. Or why some team members drive you crazy. 

No style is inherently better than another. The key is balance. A high-performing board benefits from diverse perspectives and decision-making approaches.

How to Leverage Personality Insights for Your Board

Thinking about your board composition, you may want to consider what kinds of personalities are needed. Do you need take-charge people or good listeners? Do you need to develop processes or visionary ideas? What combination of personalities will help drive your organization into the future? 

Taking personality styles into account during board recruitment can help:

  • Build a well-rounded leadership team
  • Improve communication and collaboration
  • Assign board members to roles that suit their strengths
  • Anticipate and mitigate conflicts before they arise
  • Ensure better decision-making in high-stress situations

A personality assessment is just one more tool to refine your IBP and shape a board that effectively supports your nonprofit’s mission.

Final Thoughts: Be Intentional in Board Recruitment

While this might all seem overwhelming, it doesn’t have to be! You don’t need to tackle every factor at once. Start small—focus on one or two key attributes that matter most to your board.

The main idea is to be intentional about who you invite to lead your organization. And remember that you probably won’t find what you are not looking for! 

By being intentional about board recruitment, you set your organization up for stronger leadership, better collaboration, and greater impact. Start small—define your IBP and see how it transforms your board’s effectiveness.

Every nonprofit is different and has unique needs and challenges. Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss ways to advance your Board of Directors and the work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders. 

kim@athena-coco.com

Board Service Should be a Two-Way Street

When people learn that nonprofit organizations are led by all-volunteer Board of Directors, they often wonder why anyone would do that. Like, people just give their time away, and get nothing in return?!?!? And when people (or organizations) think like that, it’s hard to imagine how nonprofits exist at all!

Yet, for centuries, nonprofits have thrived with volunteer-led boards. So, what’s the secret to keeping them engaged? The key to successfully recruiting and engaging volunteer board members is rooted in a different way of thinking. 

Organizations that approach board recruiting with a “we need you, please come help us” mentality often struggle to find people willing to serve their organization. No one wants to give their precious time to an agency that is only looking to take from them. Beyond that, they don’t want to serve an organization that doesn’t even know what they need from their volunteers or how to effectively involve them. 

On the other hand, nonprofits that are clear about what they need from their board members, have healthy and well-run boards, and view the relationship as a two-way street, tend to be much more successful in recruiting. By two-way street I mean that the volunteers get meaningful value from serving the organization. 

Some of the benefits that volunteers share about their experience include:

  • Training & Education
  • Mentoring & Networking
  • Personal & Professional Growth
  • Recognition
  • Board & Leadership Experience
  • Intrinsic Value

Training & Education

Well run boards train their new board members on a wide array of topics. Educating them on the history and impact of the organization is a great place to start. Training on duties, roles, and responsibilities; as well as expectations and how to be a great board member are also good topics. On a larger scale they may provide opportunities to learn about the broader industry and advocacy efforts. 

Mentoring & Networking

In addition to formal training, serving on a board can provide a venue for informal learning. Serving side-by-side with those with more experience provides rich opportunities to observe, ask questions, and garner support. Board work is a great place to build relationships with other leaders in your community. 

Personal Growth

Are you new to leading meetings? Building consensus? Speaking in front of others? Leading initiatives? If so, nonprofit governance is a great place to develop or sharpen these skills. And it’s a super safe setting to do it in. The other people you are serving with are probably working on the same skills, or they remember being in your shoes. Not only that – you’re there to help, so you get a lot of grace as you are finding your way. 

Recognition

Serving on a board is a wonderful way to become known in your community. By being willing to step up and help, you are viewed as a leader. Additionally, many organizations have recognition programs to acknowledge and celebrate their most engaged volunteers. Things like awards, public acknowledgements, and media spotlights are not uncommon.

Board & Leadership Experience

Gaining experience in nonprofit governance—understanding board operations, parliamentary procedures, teamwork, and problem-solving—makes you a valuable asset to other boards and organizations. By establishing yourself as a confident leader who takes initiative and gets things done, you create new opportunities for yourself. Over time, you’ll have the ability to choose the causes that matter most to you and shape your impact in the community. Plus, the leadership skills you develop through volunteer service often translate into valuable professional opportunities.

Intrinsic Value

Many people are drawn to board service by an intrinsic motivation—the deep fulfillment that comes from helping others, giving back, and strengthening the community. Being part of something bigger than yourself is a powerful experience. Organizations that effectively communicate their mission and connect board members to their impact can tap into this motivation, fostering passionate and committed volunteers.

Board service should absolutely be about volunteering based on passion to advance the nonprofit, not for personal gain. Not only that, volunteers get out of the experience what they put into it. That doesn’t mean that nonprofits shouldn’t provide value back to the volunteers.

Organizations that want to recruit quality board members may want to think about the experience as a two-way street. That means knowing what you need from your volunteers, setting clear expectations and holding them accountable, running quality meetings, respecting their time, providing feedback, educating and supporting them, and much more! In short, the best way to recruit and retain amazing volunteers? Run a high-functioning, well-structured board that values and supports its members.

Saving the World is Hard Work, But You Don’t Have to Do It Alone

Community is the foundation to success

Leading a nonprofit is a labor of love, but let’s be real—it’s also incredibly hard work. You’re out there making an impact, solving problems, and strengthening communities. The truth is, you shouldn’t have to do it alone.

That’s why I’m thrilled to introduce the Nonprofit Leaders Lounge, a space designed just for cause-driven leaders like you.

What is the Nonprofit Leaders Lounge?

The Lounge is a community created to support nonprofit leaders in tackling the unique challenges of governance, leadership, and sustainability. It’s more than a resource hub—it’s a place to connect with others who’ve been in your shoes and are just as committed to creating change.

Here’s why I believe this space is so important:

  1. Leadership Shouldn’t Fall on One Person’s Shoulders
    The purpose of a Board of Directors is to distribute the workload and ensure diverse perspectives are heard. But building a high-impact board doesn’t happen by chance—it takes intentionality, tools, and time to establish a strong culture and shared mission.
  2. It’s Lonely at the Top
    Let’s face it: being the leader of a nonprofit can feel isolating. When you’re trying to figure out how to recruit board members, lead your team, successfully run operations, plan for the future, and deliver impact, it’s tough to find someone who “gets it.” The Lounge connects you with peers and experts who understand your challenges and can help you work through them.
  3. Your Board is the Key to Your Success
    As a nonprofit founder or executive director, when you recruit board members, you’re essentially hiring your boss. That’s a big decision! For board chairs or members, the stakes are just as high—you’re taking responsibility for a mission, a business, and the people your organization serves.

Curating a thoughtful, healthy board is the cornerstone of a sustainable nonprofit.

Why I’m So Passionate About This Work:

  1. No one should have to save the world alone.
  2. When you engage volunteers effectively, your impact is amplified. Their knowledge, skills, and connections accelerate your mission.
  3. Working together strengthens communities. Bringing diverse perspectives to solve critical social issues builds lasting change.

What You’ll Find in The Lounge

The Lounge offers three levels of engagement to meet your needs:

  • 🥰 Free Resources:
    This level is perfect for anyone looking for tools, quick tips, bite-sized learning opportunities, networking, and answers to your most burning questions. You’ll get access to downloadable resources, mini Knowledge Nugget courses, and online tools that make leading a nonprofit just a little easier.
  • 😀 Community Membership:
    For a small monthly fee, you’ll unlock deeper resources, live office hours, and courses that focus on board development skills. This is your chance to ask questions, share your challenges, and grow alongside other nonprofit leaders.
  • 😍 Grow and Learn (Coming in the New Year):
    For those ready to take a deep dive, this a la carte section offers coaching, consulting, and advanced coursework. It’s designed to help you transform your Board of Directors into a high-performing team and create lasting change for your organization.

Outcomes You Can Expect

When you invest in your board and leadership skills, the results ripple across your organization:

  • A stronger, more sustainable nonprofit.
  • A board aligned with your mission and values.
  • The confidence and tools to tackle your biggest challenges.

And here’s the best part—you’re not just creating change for your organization; you’re building a foundation that strengthens your community and amplifies your impact!

Join the Movement

The Nonprofit Leaders Lounge has officially launched, just in time to be your early holiday gift! 🎁

If you’re ready to:

  • Build the board of your dreams,
  • Grow your leadership skills, and
  • Connect with like-minded peers…

…this is your invitation to join us here. 

Let’s Do This Together

Saving the world is hard work, but your efforts don’t go unnoticed. By investing in yourself and your board, you’re paving the way for even greater impact.

Let’s connect for a quick Discovery Call if you’d like to learn more. I can’t wait to hear your thoughts and ideas. In fact, I’m so interested in what you would like to see included, if I use your suggestion to improve The Lounge, you’ll get a free month of full access to the paid community!

Because no one should have to save the world alone.