Expect More, Get More: The Key to Energizing Your Nonprofit Board of Directors

Nonprofit boards are essential to the success of any organization, yet leaders often tell me that they find themselves frustrated when board members don’t seem as engaged or proactive as they’d like (or need). 

If you’ve ever felt like your board isn’t living up to its potential, you’re not alone. Many nonprofit leaders struggle with the same issue. However, the key to transforming a disengaged board into an active force for good may lie in one simple yet often overlooked factor: expectations.

Are Your Expectations Clear?

One of the most common reasons for board underperformance is a lack of clear expectations. Nonprofit leaders frequently tell me that their governance volunteers are not doing what they want or need them to do. But when I dig a little deeper, it becomes apparent that the root cause is often that these expectations were never properly communicated.

In fact, many nonprofits are grappling with board engagement issues. Improving board recruitment, engagement, and effectiveness has become a major priority for nonprofits, yet organizations still struggle with outlining clear roles and expectations for their board members. 

Without clarity, board members may either pursue their own paths or contribute very little to the organization.

“Clarity breeds mastery.” — Robin Sharma

Setting and communicating expectations upfront is the foundation for a successful board. Most people wouldn’t take a paid job without a clear understanding of their responsibilities, and we shouldn’t expect any less for our volunteers. They deserve the same clarity and support as paid staff.

So how can nonprofit leaders begin to create clarity around the expectations of their board members?

Step 1: Define What You Need from Your Board

Before you can communicate your expectations, you first need to define what your organization truly needs from its board members. This involves taking a step back and evaluating your nonprofit’s current needs, challenges, goals, and long-term vision.

Nonprofits that take a strategic approach to board recruitment and governance report better engagement and higher board effectiveness. 

For example, developing clear criteria for board candidates, including aligning their skills with the organization’s mission, has proven to be a key strategy in filling gaps and enhancing board performance. In fact, periodic reviews of board composition help nonprofits identify where additional skills or diversity may be needed to drive their mission forward.

Questions to guide this process:

  • What skills or expertise do we need on our board to achieve our mission?
  • What specific roles should board members play in fundraising, strategy, and governance?
  • How can board members contribute to addressing critical issues?

Once you’ve identified these needs, you can create detailed descriptions for board roles that align with your organization’s mission and goals.

Step 2: Strengthen Board Onboarding and Orientation

How comprehensive is your onboarding process? Boards that invest in thoughtful onboarding tend to experience higher levels of engagement. This can include training sessions that cover not only the nonprofit’s history and goals but also best practices for governance and risk management.

Consider these elements when onboarding:

  • Board orientation sessions: These can include briefings on the nonprofit’s history, mission, and current challenges.
  • Board manuals: Provide a resource that outlines expectations, responsibilities, and the roles each member is expected to play in governance and decision-making.
  • Mentorship opportunities: Pair new members with experienced ones to ease the transition and encourage immediate engagement.

By investing in a structured onboarding process, you give new members the tools they need to hit the ground running, ensuring that they’re not only aligned with your mission, but also prepared to contribute effectively.

Step 3: Build a Culture of Engagement and Accountability

“The strength of the team is each individual member. The strength of each member is the team.” — Phil Jackson

Keeping board members engaged is just as important as bringing them on board. Disengagement across a board will only get in the way of you achieving your goals. Regular communication, opportunities for development, and meaningful tasks are essential to keeping board members motivated and invested in the organization’s success.

Here are some ideas for how you can build stronger engagement:

  • Offer continuous learning opportunities: Provide training on governance best practices and offer workshops that address sector-specific challenges, such as rising concerns over climate-related risks or governance oversight.
  • Conduct annual evaluations: Evaluate both individual contributions and the collective performance of the Board of Directors. These evaluations can help identify gaps and provide opportunities for board members to refocus on areas that need attention.
  • Encourage open dialogue: Foster a culture where board members feel comfortable sharing their ideas and concerns. This open communication creates a sense of ownership and responsibility for the organization’s success.

Additionally, be sure to recognize and celebrate the contributions of your board members. Acknowledging their impact not only strengthens their connection to the mission, but also fosters a positive board culture.

Step 4: Retain and Renew Board Energy

Recruiting new board members is important, but retention is equal to this. To keep your board vibrant and engaged long-term, it’s important to continually refresh its composition and energy.

 This strategy is echoed by many nonprofits, who report success when conducting periodic reviews of their board’s makeup to ensure they are recruiting individuals with diverse skills and perspectives. Boards that focus on succession planning and rotate leadership positions regularly avoid burnout and inject fresh ideas into the organization’s governance.

Here are some ways to keep your board thriving:

  • Conduct periodic reviews: Regularly assess the board’s composition to identify areas where additional skills or new perspectives might be needed or helpful.
  • Encourage succession planning: Ensure that leadership positions on the board are regularly rotated, allowing for fresh ideas and preventing burnout.
  • Cultivate a culture of service: Make sure board members understand that their contributions are making a real difference. When their work feels connected to the mission, they’re more likely to stay engaged and committed.

One of the biggest contributors to retaining board members is quality leadership. A healthy culture and mindful leadership makes people want to stay. Not only that, it attracts others who want to be part of a strong organization! 

Bringing It All Together

Nonprofit boards have the potential to be incredible assets for organizations, helping to guide strategic direction, expand networks, and drive fundraising efforts. However, to supercharge this potential, expectations must be clear from the start, and engagement should be fostered continuously. 

You’ll then be well on your way to creating a powerhouse board that is aligned with your organization’s mission.

Every nonprofit is different and has unique needs and challenges. Email me at Kim@Athena-CoCo.com, or schedule a Discovery Call if you would like to discuss ways to advance your Board of Directors and the work of your agency.

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com

Passive to Powerhouse: Transform Your Board of Directors and Enhance Your Impact!

Picture a passionate nonprofit leader sitting at her desk, head in hands, wondering how to get her board more engaged. The last meeting barely made an impact, and when it came time to discuss fundraising strategies, most board members suddenly became very interested in their phones. 

Sound familiar?

I’ve seen this scenario play out countless times in my years working with nonprofits. One executive director said, “I feel like I’m herding cats, not leading a board.” It’s a common frustration, but it doesn’t have to be this way!

The truth is that an effective Board of Directors can be the rocket fuel that propels a nonprofit to new heights of impact and success, but boards often become passive observers rather than active partners in furthering the organization’s mission.

The Nonprofit Board Dilemma

When nonprofit leaders come to me for help, their concerns often revolve around a few key issues:

  • Disengaged board members who show up for meetings, but contribute little else
  • Lack of strategic direction from the board, leaving the staff to navigate complex decisions alone
  • Difficulty in recruiting board members with the right skills and passion
  • Boards that don’t understand their roles in fundraising and community outreach

These challenges don’t just create headaches for nonprofit leaders; they can significantly hinder an organization’s ability to fulfill its mission and serve its community effectively.

The Path to a Powerhouse Board

So, how do we transform a passive board into a powerhouse of leadership and impact? It starts with a strategic approach to board development.

Every nonprofit is unique, and so are its board development needs. One size does not fit all. I often start by helping organizations conduct a thorough assessment of their current board composition and the specific skills and perspectives they need to drive their mission forward.

Vague responsibilities are a recipe for disengagement. I’ve seen the light bulb moment when board members finally understand what’s expected of them. Suddenly, they’re not just attending meetings, they are actively contributing their expertise and connections.

Gone are the days of recruiting board members simply because they’re willing to serve. We need to be strategic, identifying individuals whose skills, networks, and passions align with the organization’s needs. And once they’re on board, a robust onboarding and engagement process is crucial.

A Six-Month Journey to Excellence

Recognizing the need for a structured approach to board development, I’ve created a six-month program designed to guide nonprofits through this transformative process. Each month builds on the last, addressing critical areas of board functionality and engagement.

We start by assessing your unique needs and setting clear expectations. Then, we dive into strategic recruitment, effective onboarding, and fostering meaningful engagement. By the end of the six months, you’ll have the tools and strategies to cultivate a board that doesn’t just show up but is ready to drive your mission forward!

Is This Program Right for You?

As someone who’s been in your shoes, leading nonprofits and grappling with board challenges, I understand the hesitation to invest time and resources in board development. 

But ask yourself:

  • Is it easy to keep your board engaged beyond monthly meetings?
  • Is your board actively contributing to fundraising and strategic planning?
  • Do you have a clear, effective process for recruiting and onboarding new board members?

If you answered “no” to any of these questions, this program could be the game-changer your organization needs.

Ready to Transform Your Board?

Imagine having a board that not only understands your challenges but actively works alongside you to overcome them. A board that brings diverse skills, connections, and resources to the table, propelling your nonprofit towards greater impact.

This isn’t just a dream; it’s an achievable reality. And it starts with a single step.

I invite you to book a call with me to discuss your organization’s unique needs and explore how this six-month journey could transform your board from passive to powerhouse. Together, we can build a board that doesn’t just support your mission – but supercharges it!

 

Kim is a mom, lover of being active and the outdoors, and helper of nonprofit leaders.
kim@athena-coco.com